24 Hour Museum - official guide to UK museums, galleries, exhibitions and heritage
Gateway to Over 3,000 UK museums, galleries and heritage attractions
Skip to navigation
Art Fund Foils Fraudster In £500,000 Paintings Bequest Swindle
By Caroline Lewis
10/04/2008
Image: Painting of a large desert fortification
One of the paintings, by David Roberts, now with rightful owners National Galleries of Scotland. © The Art Fund
The Art Fund turned from national art charity to detective in a turn of events that nearly saw the rightful owners lose out on a valuable collection of paintings.
The National Galleries of Scotland (NGS) have now welcomed the works, which were left to them via The Art Fund in a will in 1998.
Suspicions were aroused following the death of artist and collector Helen Guiterman, who had bequested six oil paintings and 51 watercolours by Victorian artist David Roberts to The Art Fund in her will. She had agreed with the charity that they would be given to the National Galleries of Scotland, to complement their existing collection by the Scottish artist.
However, the paintings, valued at £501,350 never materialised, leading The Art Fund into its investigations.
The trail led back to one Shaun Gray, grandson of Guiterman's cousin. He claimed to be her executor, and indeed had power of attorney signed by the deceased in 1997, but when questioned gave varying accounts of what had happened to the collection. Eventually, he backtracked and told the charity that Helen Guiterman had changed her will, and had not, in fact, left the paintings to The Art Fund.
Image: Photo of a woman handling two paintings with white gloves on
The acquisitions are several years late due to the fraudster who attempted to get his hands on them. © The Art Fund
The alarm was raised, and, following extensive police investigations, aided by HM Revenue and Customs, Gray pleaded guilty to charges of forging the will and false accounting. He was given a three-year prison sentence for his deeds, in which he attempted to sign over Helen Guiterman's entire estate to himself.
It has taken two years since then for the paintings to be legally assigned to the National Galleries of Scotland, during which time The Art Fund rescued them and arranged for their care.
“Helen Guiterman was a devoted collector of the work of David Roberts, who, during his lifetime, was one of the best-known and most influential 19th century British artists," said David Barrie, Director of The Art Fund.
"The Art Fund has gone to great lengths to ensure that her generous wishes are fulfilled and I’m delighted that this impressive collection will at last join the National Galleries of Scotland.”
The 19th century Scottish artist David Roberts, born in 1796, was popular and critically acclaimed during his lifetime. Yet he had tended to be overlooked until the extensive research of artist and enthusiast Helen Guiterman.
Image: Painting of nuns in a convent room
The paintings will go on show in 2009. © The Art Fund
Roberts (1796-1864), the son of a shoemaker based near Edinburgh, was an apprentice herald painter, then a house painter and theatre scene painter before he submitted paintings for exhibition in the 1820s.
He was the first independent, professional artist to travel so widely in the Near East. Following extended trips to Spain and Egypt he created a large collection of material, prints of which brought him widespread acclaim.
Helen, a graduate of the Slade School, became interested in Roberts in the 1960s after acquiring two works by him. Finding little information about him, though, she spent 30 years researching his life and work. She traced his descendants and surviving journals and letters, and travelled to many of the places he painted. She selected and catalogued three exhibitions of his work, including a full retrospective at the Barbican in 1986.
Drawings from the David Roberts collection will be included in the exhibition 'Imagining Spain: From Goya to Picasso, The British and Spain’ from July to October 2009 at the National Gallery Complex.
The Art Fund (www.artfund.org) provides an important service to collectors who wish to give or bequeath works to public collections. It is uniquely placed to help donors identify the ideal recipient or recipients for a single work of art or collections of works and is committed to ensuring that museums and galleries care for the works and respect donor’s wishes in perpetuity.
National Gallery Of Scotland (National Galleries Of Scotland)
Fine Art, The Mound, Edinburgh, EH2 2EL, Lothian, Scotland
Open: Museum:
Sat-Wed 1000-1730
Thurs-Fri 1000-2030
Great Court:
Mon-Wed 0900-2100
Thurs-Sat 0900-2300
Sun 0900-1800
Related Articles
Leading Academics Call For Art Funding Support In Wake Of Titian Pledge
Art Fund Donates £1 Million To Save Titian's Diana And Actaeon
Museums And Galleries Get Behind Cultural Olympiad Weekend
Robert Burns Collection Among Scottish Museums Achieving Recognised Status
English And Scottish Galleries Join Forces To Save Historic Bridgewater Collection
Kaleidoscope - Scottish National Gallery New Acquisitions
National Gallery Of Scotland - Impressionism And Scotland
E-news registration
E-mail story to a friend
Tell us what you think
National Portrait Gallery Acquires Tudor Double Portrait
Sheffield Metal Master Wins Museum's Inaugural Design Award
DCMS Launches Consultation Into The Future Of World Heritage Sites
A Selection Of Festive Fairs - Fun Days and Exhibitions
Royal Society Announces Plans For 350th Anniversary
Art Website ArtisanCam Wins Coveted Children's BAFTA
Former Floorboards Of Founding Father Franklin Facilitate Funny Four
Mark Leckey Wins The 2008 Turner Prize And Scoops £25,000
Library Thief Update: Sentencing Adjourned Until January 16, 2009
Fund Aims To Realise Long-Standing Campaign For Cardiff City Museum
Culture Secretary Slaps Export Ban On George I Chandelier
Shakespeare's Globe Costumes Go On Show In Nottingham
Britglyph Art Campaign Uses Web To Make Mass Geoglyph
Inaugural Awards Ceremony Honours UK Arts Philanthropists
Rare Silver Cup Commemorating Coronation Of Charles II Is Saved For The Nation
London Fire Brigade Museum Escapes Closure - For Now
Another Busy Year For Archaeology On Orkney In 2008
Severndroog Castle To Be Restored Thanks To Lottery Grant
Search this site
Home Page
News Page
Exhibition Page
What's On
Trails Page
Website of the Week
Letters Page
Welsh Home
Graphical Version
Copyright © 24 Hour Museum
Information published here was believed to be correct at the time it was prepared. Welsh language pages developed with CYMAL: Museums Archives and Libraries Wales, funded by the Welsh Assembly Government.